~This
essay was previously published in the North American Review (2003) and
was cited as a notable essay in The Best American Essays 2004.
In
Germany in 1981, miniature studs and thin gold hoops sparkled on young men’s ears
like the white lights decorating the Christkindlmarkt in December. These
same men wore gauzy Indian-print scarves wrapped loosely around their necks and
clogs on their feet—a distinctly European, somewhat hippyish look that I didn’t
have the nerve to try. The androgyny of these fashions—folds of flower against
bristled neck, callused skin exposed through open heel—bypassed language but
sank deep into the ground of my body. It was the pierced ear I was most
fascinated by: unarticulated symbol, small glitter against flesh, subtle enough
to be mistaken for a bead of sweat.
A
year in a foreign country, removed from the expectations of family and the
reactions of friends, might have been the perfect time to make such a change in
appearance—undoubtedly more remarkable in 1981 than today, but still relatively
minor. Other American college students I knew did it: the artists, the pot
smokers, the ones who listened to Modern English and the Clash, not Michael
Jackson and Kim Carnes. I fell somewhere in between, hanging out with
cheerleaders one night, New Wave weedheads the next.
No
one in my family had pierced ears at the time. As I imagined it, the unspoken
rule among my mother and sisters had something to do with the pain, the body
alteration, neither of which was desirable. (It never occurred to me that no
rule prevailed, simply personal taste.) Even as I dreamed of having an
earring—a hoop, always a hoop, I knew that right away—I understood I wouldn’t
do it. It was, when you got right down to it, barbaric to punch a hole in the
skin, to deliberately cause yourself pain.
Then,
a day or a month or a year later, a man would walk by—shirt open to the sternum
and tucked loosely into jeans, sleeves rolled to the elbow to reveal forearms
muscled like braided bread, a sliver of gold haloing his lobe.